city
calling
Deep impact: Wheat crisis in Karachi 

Effects of the severe wheat crisis in Pakistan have been acutely felt across many towns of Karachi, with the business community bearing it's share of the brunt.
Mehroz Siraj Sadruddin
One of the most recent crises Pakistan faced hit the homes and kitchens of almost every Pakistani. Prices of flour rose due to a shortage of wheat supplies in the country, making this staple and usually affordable food quite unaffordable for the common man. 

hyderabad spirit
With one hand tied behind his back…

There are people all around us who can serve as inspiration to look beyond immediate obstacles to find a way out. Zameer Ahmed Khan learnt a skill and uses it to earn a living despite his handicap.
By Adeel Pathan
Disability is no longer a taboo subject in Pakistan. Population explosion, an increasing aging population, chronic diseases such as diabetes and osteoarthritis, malnutrition, injuries due to war and violence, occupational injuries, sports injuries, large-scale environmental pollution, increasing road traffic in the industrialized areas are some of the factors known to contribute to disability.

The way we were
Naini Tal days

By Kaleem Omar

Twosie Thompson was called "Twosie" because he got two annas pocket money on Wednesdays and two on Saturdays. The rest of us got seven annas a week – three on Wednesday and four on Saturday. But Hemang Dixit, a boy from Nepal who went on to become a doctor and royal paediatrician to the King of Nepal's children, got eleven annas a week, under special instructions to the Sherwood school authorities from his father. 

karachicharacter
Sometimes they come back…
By Amina Baig
Faqir Mohammad is someone one wouldn't always see in Karachi. He moves to the city every winter, when his hometown, in Chaman becomes cold, snowed in and inhospitable to those seeking to make a living. Faqir has been setting his thela of dry fruits and toasted nuts at the same place in Clifton for the last seven years and plans on doing so till he can manage the commute. Faqir is one of the most uncomplicated people one can ever come across. He has great attachment and loyalty towards his hometown and the only one he has to Karachi is the livelihood he earns, which he is grateful for.



city
calling
Deep impact: Wheat crisis in Karachi 
Effects of the severe wheat crisis in Pakistan have been acutely felt across many towns of Karachi, with the business community bearing it's share of the brunt.

One of the most recent crises Pakistan faced hit the homes and kitchens of almost every Pakistani. Prices of flour rose due to a shortage of wheat supplies in the country, making this staple and usually affordable food quite unaffordable for the common man. Karachi, with its population of over 16 million people bore the consequences of this crisis. At general and (government established) utility stores across Karachi, customers have been facing the eye of the crisis. Standing in long lines, during cold and dry weather is surely a daunting task. However, their efforts and patience have not paid off completely as the government has been supplying wheat of a low quality to these outlets.

 As a result, apart from the average Karachiite who is paying up to five rupees for a single piece of roti (bread), retailers in Karachi have taken a direct hit as well, with profits plummeting by almost a whopping 50 per cent.

One of the most adversely affected towns in Karachi is Shah Faisal Town. "Wheat supplies are irregular," says Rafiq, who owns a general store in the area falling within the limits of Unit 109. "I have not had wheat since the last 25 days," he adds.

Though the government has lowered prices to 18 rupees per kg, the quality of wheat being supplied has been compromised too. "Low quality wheat is being supplied, locally produced wheat was of much better quality," claims Rafiq. "Prices may have lowered," he says, "but so has the standard of wheat being supplied." Rafiq is not the not the only one to have claimed this.

Shopkeepers in different parts of Shah Faisal Town voice similar opinions. A general store owner in Shah Faisal Colony 1, Aamir Atari, says that in his locality, wheat is being purchased by retailers at 17.75 rupees per kg. Now when the selling price of wheat is 18 rupees per kg, there is no sustainable profit for shopkeepers who are selling lower quality and imported wheat at a cost-to-cost basis.

"The flour that is being sold in utility stores over here is not eatable," claims Aamir. Subsequent visits to general stores in the town confirm this fact. Aamir alleges that utility stores are selling adulterated wheat at 13 rupees per kg. "Those who purchased flour from utility stores are now regretting doing so," says Aamir.

Profitability has suffered because of the grave crisis that was created last year. When wheat was being sold at  22 to  25 rupees per kg, it was learnt that traders and shopkeepers were making a net profit of two to three rupees per kilogram of wheat that was sold to the customers. Today, the maximum profit being made by these small business owners is a mean 50 paisas. Keeping this fact in mind, Mr Atari explains that "profits made on a 40 kg sacks have fallen from 90 to 20 rupees." These 20 rupees, he adds, "are taken by transporters who bring the wheat to our shops."

When questioned, Mohammed Salman, who owns and operates a medium size general store near Shama Plaza, confirmed to Kolachi that "there have been no profits at all, but quality of the wheat has still been compromised." However, shopkeepers are still willing to stock and sell wheat without a sustainable profit margin. Salman says this is because,"people will come to purchase other items only if we continue to stock wheat." This  observation  indicates that wheat is the most important commodity for daily consumption and purchase in Shah Faisal Town.

Local shopkeepers blame the federal government and black sheep within the whole system for creating the wheat crisis. According to Salman, "good quality wheat has been witheld by mill owners owing to financial reasons." This is mainly because of the high cost of wheat in the international markets and the fact that hoarders had to 'get rid' of the old stocks first.

Analysts, economists and press reports have confirmed many of the claims of shop owners in Shah Faisal Town.

Economist Dr Abid Soleri, tells Kolachi; "Industrial mafias are behind the hoarding of wheat. This includes the aristocratic classes of various political parties who are also policy makers. They are the same people who created the sugar crisis two years ago."

Commenting on this trend of hoarding, Iqbal Dawood, who is the Chairman of Pakistan Flour Mills Association (PFMA), says that, "a list of 50 hoarders was presented to former Prime Minister Shaukat Aziz, but no action whatsoever was taken."

The situation in Gulshan-e-Iqbal Town is more or less similar to that in Shah Faisal Town. Shopkeepers report reducing profitability and irregularities in wheat supplies, the quality of which is nothing to write home about anyway.

"Profits have been reduced by 50 per cent; the crisis is still very much at large in the area," says Abdul Rahim, who owns a general store near the NIPA flyover. He further says that while he managed to sell around 60 kg of wheat everyday before the crisis, at a profit of 10 rupees per kilogram, sales and profits have both taken a nosedive now. Procurement of wheat too has been a problem for him.

Abdul Ghaffar, owner of a general store enmeshed inside a residential locality in Gulshan-e-Iqbal, says that, "pure, finely ground wheat is not available at the moment." He claimed that sales of "mixed atta (flour)" have gone down from 100 to 30 kg, after a sharp rise in buying earlier this month.

"Utility stores are the kings of corruption," suggests former President, Sindh chapter of PFMA, Mohammed Yousuf.

Critiquing the government's failed policies of wheat distribution, he alleges that some people with vested interests were involved in the embezzlement of wheat. "End consumers," he says, "are the ones suffering most at the hands of negligence by the authorities."

The situation however in another major town, North Nazimabad, has been pretty stable despite the recent crisis. This is because most shopkeepers and large departmental stores in the locality traditionally store extra stocks of commodities such as rice and wheat when they are amply available in the market. However, white ground wheat that comes directly from mills is still being sold at the exorbitant price of around 35 rupees per kg at some general stores in the locality.

There are two major reasons because of which wheat supplies in North Nazimabad have not been hurt despite the crisis in the entire city.

Firstly, most of the businesses and general stores in North Nazimabad are very close to Abdullah Flour Mills, located near Ghalib Library. Secondly, as there are two Rangers' wings between the flourmill and the library, adequate supplies to shops and general stores have been largely ensured.

Deployment of Rangers at the city's various flour mills is a measure that should have been taken a long while back to further ensure transparent supply and distribution of wheat in the city.  

 Afzal Cheema, who heads the Rangers' unit deployed at Mehran Shopping Complex, located opposite to a popular local Chinese food restaurant, stresses that "wheat was readily available at our store even after the post December 27 crisis." He adds that according to his information, "people had taken wheat from the complex to other localities and towns as well."

Iqbal Dawood, President PFMA, Sindh zone, expresses his satisfaction over the deployment of Rangers at the flour mills and has said that the required amount of wheat is finally being supplied in substantial quantities to flour mills and utility stores.

Despite several attempts, no government official could be reached for their take on the situation.

Other than some exceptional cases, Karachiites, like their middle and lower middle class country people have borne the brunt of the national wheat crisis. A detailed debate on and restructuring of Pakistan's agricultural policies is the need of the hour. The government should ensure that in the future, the mistakes committed this time are not repeated.

Adequately meeting local demands should be the first priority of the government and for accomplishing that, many analysts say that the authorities at local, provincial and federal level must take stern action against hoarders and smugglers, ban wheat exports and ensure that price tags on wheat in local markets is assigned keeping in mind the international prices of wheat.

These measures, according to many analysts, would automatically turn the tide against hoarders and smugglers, thus ensuring economic stability within and outside Karachi.

 

--Photos by

Zahid Rehman

 


hyderabad spirit
With one hand tied behind his back…
There are people all around us who can serve as inspiration to look beyond immediate obstacles to find a way out. Zameer Ahmed Khan learnt a skill and uses it to earn a living despite his handicap.

Disability is no longer a taboo subject in Pakistan. Population explosion, an increasing aging population, chronic diseases such as diabetes and osteoarthritis, malnutrition, injuries due to war and violence, occupational injuries, sports injuries, large-scale environmental pollution, increasing road traffic in the industrialized areas are some of the factors known to contribute to disability.

Though there are many medical definitions of disability, for laymen, a person who cannot perform his everyday routine properly due to a handicap can be classified as disabled person. However there are individuals who have defied these classifications and have proved themselves to be quite able despite their disabilities.

Born in 1965 in Unit-8 of Latifabad Taluka, Hyderabad, Zameer Ahmed Khan is an individual who has proved the supposed implications of disability wrong. His life is inspirational, with him making a successful living out of creating ornamental items. Zameer does this despite his handicap; he has only one arm.

Zameer lost his left armwhile working in a factory on his 15th birthday. This proved to be quite an obstacle for him as he was left-handed.

Regardless of the fact that he had lost an instrumental part of his body, Zameer was a keen footballer as well. He played at all the leading stadiums in Pakistan till 1997, as he was not allowed to attend the football World Cup in 1995. He then shifted his attention to woodcraft and creating wooden ornaments.

 

"Yes, I faced a lot of difficulties but the courage and support of my parents and other family members went a long way to encourage me," says Zameer, "my teachers too pushed me to work harder in this field." Zameer especially regards Shafiq Ahmed Khan as the teacher who taught him his art and pushed him to take it further. He admits that he was lucky, as not just his family, but his friends helped him a great deal as well.

Married in 1988, Zameer is the father of four children. His eldest son has just passed his matriculation and works part-time as a decoration-piece makerp; household expenses could not be covered with the meager salary he earns at a semi private organization.

Zameer says that his son helps him whenever he is free at home. He works day and night to earn his livelihood in a respectable manner and prefers to work instead of begging others for help.

Zameer has been participating in Koocha-e-Saqafat at Karachi Arts Council every Sunday since 2006 and sells his works of art including key chains as well as models of monuments and shrines.

A key chain is sold at 35 rupees, but it is not easy to prepare the key chain as it undergoes a number of processes before completion. However, Zameer says that the companies who want to purchase them in bulk can get them for lower prices.

Waiting for attention from concerned quarters and the government, the disabled yet capable man with his firm belief in the dignity of labour has participated in a number of exhibitions and fairs and also wants to take part in foreign exhibitions.

Zameer also teaches this art at Karachi Arts Council and tells Kolachi that not just handicapped children, but normal children as well as women visit his stall and learn the art of crafting wood into ornaments.

Thousands of people live with various forms of disability across the globe and a majority of these live in under developed conditions where education, healthcare and economic conditions are anything but optimal.

Zameer has prepared samples of key chains for various multinational as well as national companies to and earns a good income out of it. He is currently waiting for response from these companies. It would be commendable if such companies actually gave people like Zameer a shot at living better lives with their handicaps.

It is also equally important to provide support and rehabilitation services to such individuals to help them realize their potential. Zameer suggests that the government should establish centers where he and other like him can teach handicapped children such forms of art and craft to discourage the menace of beggary.

Persons with disabilities should be ensured that they have the same rights as anyone considered 'normal' to access available opportunities. It is about time that Pakistan learns that allocation of resources to people with handicaps is an investment rather than a mere medical expense.   

Zameer might not be the only handicapped person with his skill, but he can definitely be a symbol of hope and perseverance for everyone in society.

– Photos by

Mohammed Rehan


The way we were
Naini Tal days 

Twosie Thompson was called "Twosie" because he got two annas pocket money on Wednesdays and two on Saturdays. The rest of us got seven annas a week – three on Wednesday and four on Saturday. But Hemang Dixit, a boy from Nepal who went on to become a doctor and royal paediatrician to the King of Nepal's children, got eleven annas a week, under special instructions to the Sherwood school authorities from his father. We were convinced his father must be a millionaire because only a millionaire's son could get the staggering sum of eleven annas a week in pocket money. Back in those days, the mid-1940s, even an anna was a quite a lot of money. Eleven annas was a fortune. A rupee was something almost beyond our comprehension.

   Sherwood College, a boy's boarding school in Naini Tal, a pretty hill town in the Himalayan terai, and the summer capital of the United Provinces in the days of the British Raj, was founded in 1860 by an Anglican mission. It was originally called the Diocesan Boys School. In 1937, however, its name was changed to Sherwood College, after the famous forest near the English midlands town of Nottingham where Robin Hood and his band of merry men had once dallied – hunting the king's deer, robbing from the rich and giving to the poor, and generally having a rare old time of it, with venison feasts, archery contests and frequent fracas with the Sheriff of Nottingham and the evil Prince John.

   The school had four houses: Robin Hood, Friar Tuck, Alan a Dale and Little John. When you joined the school, you had to choose the house you wanted to be in. But then you had to stick to that house throughout your years at school. When I joined in 1943, I chose Robin Hood, thinking that since he had been the leader of that band of outlaws, the house named after him must also be the best. As I later discovered to my chagrin, however, Robin Hood, far from being Top House, was actually Jugh House – "jhug" being school slang for coming last in the inter-house competition.. Friar Tuck was Top House. 

   This discovery came as a dire blow, because whereas boys who were members of the Top House got to drink a couple of sips of orange squash from the Champion House Trophy cup on Founder's Day, boys in the Jhug House got nothing and had to content themselves with looking on enviously as the Top House boys drank their orange squash. This may not seem like such a big deal today, but in those days our lives at school revolved around food and we would happily have committed murder for half a banana or a few sips of orange squash.

   I got my chance to get a crack at that orange squash when I rejoined Sherwood in March 1947, after a year away from Naini Tal at a school in Calcutta, where my parents were living at the time. Since readmissions were treated as fresh admissions at Sherwood, you were again entitled to join a house of your choice. As Friar Tuck had been Top House for four years running, I naturally chose it as my house, thinking that it would be Top House again.

   Come Founder's Day, July 1947, however, and Friar Tuck – which up to that stage had been leading in the points table in the Top House competition – got pipped at the post when my cousin Ajaz Anis, who was in Alan a Dale house and was one of the school's star athletes – won all the sprint events as well as the long jump, high jump and hop-step-and-jump events, putting Alan a Dale into first place by the skin of its teeth. So it was the smirking Alan a Dale boys who got to drink that orange squash from the Champion House Trophy cup, while we disconsolate Friar Tuck boys looked on, muttering curses under our breaths.

   Because I was Ajaz's cousin, the Friar Tuck boys all blamed me for the defeat. I even got into a couple of fights on this account with two boys from my house, though I kept trying to explain to them that I was as upset over Alan a Dale's victory as they were. That was my first lesson in the philosophy that life just isn't fair sometimes.

   Whenever a fight broke out between two boys at Sherwood, the cry would ring out: "Scrap on board behind the bogs!" The "bogs" were school slang for the loos. And it was behind the bogs that most fights took place, since that was the one spot in the school grounds the masters were unlikely to visit. They had their own loos. Though we never actually saw these masters' loos, they must have existed, because even the masters must have had to go to the loo sometimes. Or could it be that they were given to using the nooks and crannies of Naini Tal's wooded hillsides as loos, in a sort of Raj version of the local "jungle jaana hai" practice? 

   Set around the peaceful Naina lake, or "tal," hence the name, Naini Tal was very much a green and pleasant land that, back in the mid-nineteenth century, had immediately appealed to the homesick Brits, who were reminded of the Cumbrian Lake District. It was 'discovered' by a Mr Barron and he had his yacht carried up there in 1840.

   The Naini Tal Boat Club, whose wooden clubhouse still graces the edge of the lake, became the fashionable focus of the community. Disaster struck on 16 th September, 1880 when a major landslide occurred, burying 151 people in the Assembly Area and creating the recreation ground now known as the Flats. We used to be allowed down to the Flats every other weekend to watch a movie at the Capitol Cinema, which also had a roller-skating rink attached to it. The rink's cafeteria served the best potato chips I've ever eaten. There were no "freedom fries" in those days.

   During the high season, when the cool environs of Naini Tal saw the advent of hundreds of visitors from the hot and steamy plains, the Mall was closed to cars for most of the day. Cycle rickshaws, mountain ponies and dandis (palanquins carried by Tibetan porters) took passengers along the mile-long Mall between the bazaars at Talli Tal ("lake's foot"), at its south end, and Malli Tal ("lake's head"), to the north-west.

   The bus stand was in Talli Tal, and it was there that we boys would disembark from the buses bringing us up to school in early March, at the beginning of the school year, from the railhead at Kathgodam, at the edge of the plains 22 miles to the south. Halfway up the winding road from Kathgodam was the hamlet of Joli Kot, which was famous for its honey. The whole heavily forested region teemed with wildlife in those days. This was tiger country, made famous by the legendary Jim Corbett – a resident of Naini Tal and the author of the worldwide best seller "The Man-Eaters of Kumaon". 

   Corbett was greatly revered by the local people for shooting tigers that had developed a liking for human flesh. In later life, he was instrumental in setting up the Corbett Tiger Reserve, established in 1936 as India's first national park. Corbett became a conservationist, long before the birth of the worldwide conservation movement, and eventually shot more wildlife with his camera than with his gun. In 1938, a grateful government awarded him the unique honour of "Freedom of the Forests". He is the only person ever to receive this distinction.

   Jim Corbett never married, but his younger brother, Tom, did. Tom's son, confusingly also named Tom, joined the British army and rose to the rank of lieutenant-general, serving in the Iraq theatre during World War II. The younger Tom had two children, both boys. The older boy was named Jim (after his famous great-uncle) and the younger boy was name Michael. Like their great-uncle Jim Corbett, young Jim and Michael Corbett were both at Sherwood with me. Jim was in my class, and Michael was two classes below us.

   In the years since then, I've managed to keep track of the whereabouts of several Sherwood boys who were with me at school, including Ravi Dayal, who was married to the daughter of famed Indian author Kushwant Singh, and headed Oxford University Press in India before setting up his own publishing firm; and Salman Haider, who stood second in the whole of India in the civil service examination and then joined the Indian Foreign Service, retiring as Foreign Secretary a few years ago. Ravi died last year, and is deeply missed by everybody who had known him.

   I don't know what became of Jim and Michael Corbett, but I would like to think that, like their famous great-uncle, they spent their lives roaming the forests of Naini Tal and the Kumaon.

 


karachicharacter
The art-supply man

Amina Baig

Wazir Ahmed is a familiar face to art students; he works in an art supply store and is surprisingly polite and helpful to the usually high-strung students who crowd his store everyday.

Wazir moved to Karachi for the employment opportunities were better and more in the metropolis than in his "quiet, sleepy," village. He isn't married, but enjoys spending time with his brothers'children and hopes to secure their future as well as his brothers'.

 

Kolachi: When did you move to Karachi?

Wazir: I moved here around 10 years ago, after completing my education.

 

Kolachi: What brought you here?

Wazir: The money; I can make more money here than I can in my village in Sargodha, where I was born and brought up.

 

Kolachi: Was it difficult moving here and settling in?

Wazir: Not really, as my brothers have been settled here since '81, i just moved in with them.

 

Kolachi: What did you do initially when you moved here?

Wazir: I worked at a bookstore.

 

Kolachi: Is this what you have always wanted to do?

Wazir: I have always just wanted to make more money. Which is why I would rather move abroad, where the money is better.

 

Kolachi: Since you work in an art store, do you have an interest in the subject?

Wazir: Yes I do.

 

Kolachi: And how do you satiate that interest?

Wazir: I get to meet a lot of artists. I see students and can view their work as well. We used to get a lot of Gulgee's students as well and I enjoyed looking at their work.

 

Kolachi: You must come across all sorts of people at the shop, have you learnt more about the human nature?

Wazir: Everyone who comes here is different; we get art students and families with children. Some people complain about the quality of the things we sell even if it is very good, while some people are delighted with low quality supplies, saying they can make good use of it.

 

Kolachi: It is a terrifying thought that someone could get murdered in their own house, do you ever fear for your own safety?

Wazir: No one is really safe in Karachi, are they? When you leave your house for work in the morning you don't know if you will come back home or not.

 

Kolachi: Did the recent bout of terrorism affect business in any way?

Wazir: Yes, there are some fancy things we have like colouring books and sets and now when children ask their parents to buy them these, their parents say they don't have money to spare. There has been an economic affect for sure.

 

Kolachi: Do you miss Sargodha?

Wazir: If there was assurance that I could make the same kind of money there, I would go back. Karachi is good that way, but Sargodha's atmosphere is much better. It is peaceful, people live a very organized life, they wake up go to work and come home. We eat dinner after Maghrib prayers and go to sleep. In Karachi, you can't afford to lose a single minute, each one is tightly packed with something new and if you miss anything, it can cost you, especially in terms of work.

 

Kolachi: Elections are right around the corner, can you see the excitement in your neighbourhood?

Wazir: Both PPP and MQM fall in my constituency and there is a lot of election hustle bustle.

 

Kolachi: Do you plan on voting?

Wazir: Yes, I will vote for Mohtarma's party.

 

Kolachi:Are you enjoying all the election activity?

Wazir: I leave for work before nine and return home well after nine in the evening. I don't get to see much.

 

Kolachi: So what do you do when you do get time off?

Wazir: When I have time off from here on Sunday, I would rather make daily wages than sit idle.

 

Kolachi: And how do you accomplish that?

Wazir: I have a couple of chicken shops, I sit at those.

 

Kolachi: But when you don't feel like doing that, what do you do?

Wazir: I hang out with my nieces and nephews and help them read and draw and colour.

 

Kolachi: Is there any one place you enjoy hanging out at though?

Wazir: I like the Nisar Shaheed Park.

 

Kolachi: Did your neighbourhood get affected by the recent wheat crisis at all?

Wazir: If you go the Utility Store just off Punjab Chowrangi right now you will about 200 women lined up waiting to save two rupees off their atta shopping right now!

 

Kolachi: Has atta become that expensive?

Wazir: Yes, they're selling it for 18 rupees for a kilo and the quality isn't that great either.

 

Wazir is very focused on his aim of earning money and doing well and helping his brothers settle down comfortably, in fact he has just set up a curtain shop for one of his brothers. He says there isn't anything about Karachi that he particularly enjoys, but there isn't anything he dislikes either. Though he longs to go home someday, he is willing to move countries if it means he will earn more money. Aware and hardworking, such is Karachi's character.

|Home|Daily Jang|The News|Sales & Advt|Contact Us|


BACK ISSUES