Suffering by the sea
Kolachi looks at the problems faced by the residents in Keti Bandar - one of the marginalized coastal areas of Sindh

The contaminated water crisis
"I have admitted my three year old daughter to the hospital," cries Ghulam Hussein, a resident of Husseinabad (Hyderabad) while he waits in the crowded corridors of Liaquat University Hospital. "She fell ill after drinking the contaminated water supplied to our locality."

Selling flowers in the city by the sea
Ornaments made from fresh flowers are a Karachi speciality. You may not see a rose in bloom, but you will see it adorning a woman's hand

A clean start
There are a couple of common sights that kids in Karachi grow accustomed to  - garbage, people littering the roads, throwing empty cans and wrappers from their cars, using the roadside as a public loo and disfiguring the walls in any possible way - be it the arty graffiti or the completely artless spit stains.

The small helping hand
"Give me 10 samosas". "Give me 15 samosas". "Please hand over the bowl of chat masala". These shouts can be continuously heard at the one rupee samosa canteen in Karachi University. Famous for its delicious, small sized, one rupee samosas, this canteen, undoubtedly, is the peculiarity of the place. While visiting the shop, many people take notice of the small boy sitting inside, engrossed in the almost mechanical act of making samosas. This 16-year-old boy is Umar Aslam.

 

 

 

The fishermen of the coastal belt of District Thatta are fighting a ttle for their survival although they are playing very important in the national economy along with fishermen of other parts of the country.

However, most of the problems faced by them could be solved easily if the authorities concerned pay proper attention.

 

Role of fishery in the national economy

Fishery plays an important role in Pakistan's economy. It is considered to be an important source of livelihood for the coastal inhabitants. Apart from marine fisheries, inland fisheries (comprising of rivers, lakes, ponds, dams etc.) are also very important source of seafood. Fisheries' share in GDP, although not a large chunk, contributes substantially to the national income through export earnings. Generally, 8 billion rupees worth of fishery products are exported from Pakistan to other parts of the world. Moreover, fishery products have also big market in the country as well. But the fishermen, like those of the coastal belt of Thatta, get very little reward for their hard labour. 

 

History

Thatta is situated ninety eight kilometres, east of Karachi, on the National High National Highway, just west of the Indus River and the Arabian Sea coast. Thatta (also called Thatto in local language) was once the Sindh Capital City. It was incorporated as a municipality in 1854. The coastal belt of Thatta in which Keti Bandar, Bagan, Kharo Chhan etc are included, is almost 160 kilometres away from Karachi.   

The days have gone when the Keti Bandar was one of the richest ports of the region. The residents of Keti Bandar proudly claim that this port granted a loan to Karachi Municipal Committee during nineteenth century. This is no more in operation since 1935. Now not even the ruins of the port are visible due to sea erosion. Most of the inhabitants believe that Keti Bandar is actually the port of Daibal where Muhammad Bin Qasim along with his army arrived through ships from Iraq. There lives a caste of people called Dibla at Keti Bandar which justifies their claim to some extents.

 

Problems

Keti Bandar is a poor area and has all the problems associated with that. These include lack of schools, medical facilities and even basics like electricity. During the second regime of Benazir Bhutto in 1993 the residents of the Keti Bandar and adjoining areas were facilitated with electricity. Unfortunately, it takes months to rectify the problems if any occur in the electricity system of the area. These poor fisher folk have no contacts in high places that can get the job done. 

However, the most pervasive problem they face is lack of awareness regarding their profession, which has resulted in 60 percent decline in their fish catch.

They have been using fine woven net for fishing which is unanimously worldwide considered dangerous for the fish breed. 

Most of the fishermen of Keti Bandar and adjoining coastal localities like Kharo Chhan, Shah Bandar, Saakro etc are under the control of middlemen for earning their livelihood. A visit to Keti Bandar and adjoining areas by this correspondent revealed that the fishermen don't have direct access to Karachi market where they can get better price for their catch.

The fishermen are deeply concerned about the role of the middlemen in their areas. They are often paid only 25 percent and sometime even less price compared to prevailing market value in Karachi. According to them, when one of them directly approaches the Karachi market for selling fish, he is given reasons as to why he should sell his catch for less. One of the most common excuses, which the market players tell them, is that of lack of ice in their fish catch that means that the fish are not fresh. 

The fishermen realize that it is just an excuse to pay them less, but they don't know how to hold their own and believe that middlemen have strong connections in the Karachi market and they the fishermen being poor could not possibly break their network.

The literacy rate amongst fishermen is very low. There is a boys secondary school in Keti Bandar but this is very difficult for people of surrounding areas to reach the school and get education.

Fisherman Fateh Muhammad looks like he is in his fifties, but when inquired about his age he said that it could be 20 or 25 years. He has not even seen Karachi yet. He works at fishing boat and earns 100 to 150 rupees daily.

Fateh Muhammad claims that 10 years back he could easily earn 1000 to 2000 rupees daily due to abundance of fish in the sea.

Most of the fishermen don't have anything to do in June and July every year due to ban on prawn catching and many of them has to suffer from hunger during these days. Many of them don't have access to potable water and they often bath in sea when needed. Justice is another thing, which is very difficult to get for the fishermen of the area.

 

Access to justice

Eight-year-old innocent Altaf who was the resident of Tehsil Kharo Chhan was killed after becoming the victim of sex abuse. The relatives of the child victim  believed that 60 years old Siddique Moraj, who is the relative of an influential feudal lord in Thatta was behind the crime. They approached Police Station for registering an FIR but the SHO Saino Khan did not cooperate with them, probably because of the accused's influence.  They had been requesting him again and again but in vain as the accused had good relations with an influential personality of the area.

Afterwards, the residents of area had to protest on large scale against the attitude of the police and finally another police officer was put in charge of the case and they were successful in registering FIR against the accused ten days after the crime was committed.

 

What to do

Just when seafood is becoming more expensive all over the world and is also an increasingly popular delicacy in our country, the way the fishermen who harvest the fruit from the sea have been marginalized is a tragedy. It is also a travesty of justice. Corruption and a system that increasingly favours the rich works against them. The fisher folk of Keti Bandar do not have the means to fight back and neither do they know the way to do so. All they live on is the hope that when the Indus river flows again, their land will become fertile again and living hand to mouth will be a thing of the past.

However, the once mighty Indus has turned to a desert river bed and short of radical climate change, nothing will change that. It is up to the government to pay attention to the needs of the fishermen, who are as important to Pakistan's coastal areas as farmers are to the country.

 

Next week: Qadeer Tanoli interviews two residents of Keti Bandar

 

 

The contaminated water crisis

"I have admitted my three year old daughter to the hospital," cries Ghulam Hussein, a resident of Husseinabad (Hyderabad) while he waits in the crowded corridors of Liaquat University Hospital. "She fell ill after drinking the contaminated water supplied to our locality."

This is not an isolated case. Hundreds of people are being treated after contracting gastroenteritis and diarrhea from contaminated water. At this very hospital, children suffering from the same ailment are lined up on beds. Doctors say that the number is on the rise.

The provision of clean water to all citizens is the responsibility of state and water should be safe for drinking, according to World Health Organization standards. The condition of Hyderabad's water supply  does not measure up. Water borne diseases are claiming casualties especially now in summer.

The recent deaths in Hyderabad have finally opened the eyes of policy makers who are promising to devise a national water strategy. The policy was discussed at several levels and a few NGOs were also involved, but ground results are still not visible.

A study Swiss Coalition Development Organization study shows that only a quarter of the people of Pakistan have access to safe and sufficient drinking water. Access in rural areas is 23.5 per cent while in urban areas it stands at 30 per cent. The Pakistan Council of Research and Water Resources (PCRWR) estimates that 40 per cent of all illnesses in the country are water related and according to international health agencies, 200,000 children are reported dead due to water related stomach ailments.

Concern over the rapid contamination of existing ground water supplies continues to be raised at seminars and while the government pledges a network of purification plants and safe water supplies by 2008, it is estimated that the deaths caused by contaminated water will continue to rise. In the meantime, Hyderabad is bearing the brunt of it.

Two years ago about 50 people, including minors, lost their lives after the toxic water of Manchar Lake was released into the Indus River water supply to citizens of Hyderabad. This year, unfortunate deaths have started occurring, especially of minors who cannot survive the brutal heat wave along with unhealthy water. Four children have expired so far, while thousands have been admitted for treatment. District government officials claim that the situation is not alarming and that the outbreak of gastro was not a result of consumption of contaminated water. The Dean Faculty of Natural Sciences, University of Sindh Jamshoro, Dr Mohammed Yar Khuhawar has another story to tell.

Dr Khuhawar collected five water samples from River Indus, above Kotri Barrage, Jamshoro Hyderabad Bridge, Husseinabad pumping station, Unit No.12 Latifabad pumping station and pumping distribution system at Unit No. 12, Latifabad. He discovered that the water above Kotri barrage indicated TDS (total dissolved salts) at 212 PPM, well within the permissible limit of 500PPM (parts per million) of WHO. However, downstream Kotri barrage water quality of river Indus wasn't so good and water supply pumping stations of Husseinabad and Latifabad No.12 indicated TDS at 986PPM and 1212PPM respectively, much above the permissible limits of World Health Organization. This water should be classified as unsafe.

Director General Health Sindh, Dr Hadi Bux Jatoi confirms that thousands of gastro patients have so far been reported in the hospitals. Three children including Zaheer, a resident of Tando, Yusuf (age six), Junaid (age eight months) residents of Latifabad Unit 11, Anas, resident of Latifabad Unit 11 aged one year, all expired at Shah Bhittai Hospital Latifabad while Naila, an eight year old resident of Tando Allahyar expired at LUH Hyderabad. Occuring between May 11 to May 17, these deaths are only the recorded statistics. Many others probably go unknown.

Dr Jatoi admits that his directorate was well aware of the situation. Instructions were issued to the EDO Health Hyderabad to declare emergency in all health institutions and was advised to request water authorities for the proper chlorination of water. He was also advised to direct all ice factories to use clean and clear water. A control room was also established to monitor the situation. The District Nazim of Hyderabad was also requested to issue instructions to Wasa authorities for proper purification of water.

All health officers across the province including Karachi were directed to stock the life saving drugs and medicines at all health outlets and local authorities should be pressed for provision of safe and potable water and proper drainage of stagnant water. It was advised that health education units should motivate people to boil water before drinking it.

After the outbreak of the gastroenteritis, District Government took 'multi-dimensional' steps to prevent gastroenteritis and outbreak of any epidemic in the district.

District Nazim Kanwar Naveed Jamil, taking a preventive measure, ordered that water supply from the water works of Husseinabad and Latifabad Unit No.4 be suspended with immediate effect on account of substandard quality of water due to non-release of fresh water from downstream Kotri Barrage for many months. The areas hooked to these water were being provided filter water through Thandi Sarak Pumping Station where the quantity of filter water has been increased and enhancement in the fleet of water tanker has been made from 4 to 12 tankers to meet the increased demand of water in these areas.

Kanwar Naveed says that round the clock monitoring of the water being supplied by WASA has also been initiated and water samples being tested after every six hours in the new filter plant laboratory to ascertain the quality of water. 

Providing details of measures, he said that injection of chlorine from various pumping stations has been intensified to make the water as Germ free and added that district health management has been assigned to launch health education campaign among the citizens and to distribute chlorine tablets to the people with free of cost.

The government has also made available as many as 0.5 million chlorine tablets and 25 drums of chlorine powder with district health department while purchase of one million more chlorine tables have been ordered for the distribution among the people.

He said that the force of Lady Health Visitors (LHVs) has been engaged in this task not only to distribute the chlorine tables but also to educate the people for purifying their water and adopting preventive measures in these of heat wave days.

A vigilance committee comprising on officers of Health and Revenue Departments has also been constituted to conduct surprise raids over the fruit and vegetable markets and take action against those involving in the sale of over ripe fruits and vegetables.

The Executive District Officer (EDO) Health Hyderabad Dr. Nazar Muhammad Junejo also confirmed that due to the prevailing heat waves the gastroenteritis has been outbreak in the district while the number of these patients was being increasing day by day.  Therefore, he directed general practitioner doctors to refer the patients of gastro-enteritis to the major hospitals with immediate effect instead of attending them at their own clinics to avoid loss of lives.

He said that in such situation awareness and cooperation of the people was very much essential in taking precautionary measures to avoid loss of life and advised the people to get their water tanks clean and chlorinated, use boiled water and milk, maintain cleanliness, avoid from use of over ripe fruits, vegetables, stale food, ice from market and keep themselves protected from sun and heat wave, as precautionary measures to avoid from the gastro-enteritis and sunstroke.

He said that the medical staff of the hospital has been made alert and required medicines have been made available to treat the patients without delay or difficulty, however the cooperation and awareness among the people in getting treatment from the major hospitals of the district at early stage and adopting care and cure methodology was essential to combat this menace.

The action the government is taking sound impressive, but it has to be remembered that it is a case of too little too late. The contamination of ground water and other water sources presents a grave threat to population. Hundreds of deaths have taken place, but as there is no awareness, they remain hidden casualties.

The calamities are rising as a consequence of a failure to take preventive measures are alarming.  Given the lower costs and higher success rates, preventive medicine must be given priority including immunization programs and the provision of safe water to all citizens.

Access to clean water should be implemented soon and completed on or before time on war footing basis otherwise alternative supplies piped in to meet community needs and provision of safe drinking water must be seen as urgent, immediate and need of people before all other necessities.

Realizing the problem, the district administration has finally made a request that irrigation authorities to release fresh water into Kotri downstream. But, it is very late. There  should be contingency plan before the start of summer each year. The sad history of Pakistan is that authorities only came into action when calamity strikes people dead. this should not be the case.

 

 

Amongst its many wonders, Punjab is blessed with a beautiful blossoming summer. Flowers blooming out of every nook and cranny make this rainbow extravaganza a treat for even those who would rather spend their time indoors with their computers. During the Punjab summer you can actually savour the fresh flowery fragrance hanging in the hot atmosphere, enjoying (if you can in the heat) the sweetness raging around.

Nature offers the lolling hills of Islamabad and Murree are bedecked with flowers of all shapes, sizes and hues. And if nature's flowery extravaganza isn't enough, cities like Lahore have shops laden with blooming colours adorning a whole street. These multi-coloured stall like flowers are hard to miss, and you can buy a huge bouquet of exotic assortment for very little. Ahh, during summer Punjab is the place to be. You must be thinking, oops, wrong article on wrong page but before you call in to tell the editorial staff of their mistake, let me tell you this is all about Karachi and its eccentricities. Then: Why this eulogy of Punjab printed in Kolachi? Well this is mainly because we can highlight what a region geographically deprived of this natural beauty can do to make itself known for whatever it has, in the flower department so to speak.

I realised this flower issue through experience. While looking for a simple gajra in one of these Punjabi cities is not that simple, you may want to learn how to make a dozen or so if you have based your dinner on a gajra theme. You cannot buy a gajra off the road like in Karachi, you will have to find the shop where these are made to order, and that too well in advance.

Secondly, not all shops offer these services (and not all cities). Thirdly, be ready to cough up a hefty amount for these, as they are not available at four for 10 rupees like in Karachi at traffic sets. Lahore should try and get with it, and provide this gajra facility considering that it is the Pakistani film city. And while we are on Lahore, the city government should provide guided tours to the film studios of yore, where historical (and good) movies were filmed, so that the next generation can get a feel of the good old days.

If you have found a flower shop ready to make these gajray, be sure to explain what you want or else you could be in for a surprise. Observe and learn:

"I would like three dozen gajras."

"We don't have ready made, you will have to place an order."

"Well I need them this evening. I want white flowers and roses."

"We only make white ones."

He showed me a sample, a single string with roses on it. I said, "I want the gajra we wear on our wrists."

He demonstrated that that these could be worn on the wrist. After half an hour and several drawings I managed to get my idea through to the man.

"Insert a single rose in these gajra."

"That will cost you."

"How much is one gajra?"

"50 rupees."

"But we get four for 10 rupees in Karachi."

At that time, I missed our cajoling gajra sellers selling their ware at every nook and cranny of Karachi the city; each with a different interesting selling line. I remember the one who told me that his gajras were magical, and anyone who wore them would fall in love with the person who gave them. And even these magical gajra were four for 20 rupees. Then there was one child who was selling gajras that he had named. There were Rekha, Sri Devi and Madhuri for the older lot, and Rani, Kareena, Karishma and Sultry Basu for the younger lot. He promised that these would make the wearer as beautiful, if not more, as these actresses. There was hardly any difference between these gajras, but he was using this ploy to lure customers.

The great thing is that flower-less Karachi offers a variety of designs for the gajras. You have the typical pure white flowers' gajra very common, available at all outlets, as well as traffic sets. Then the single rose in the white gajras, which only adds to 'the purity of love' as one gajra wallah said. What he meant by this remains a mystery. Then we have the yellow and yellow-red gajras, which are a unique design and look beautiful, especially if worn in a mehndi.

Unlike the cities of Punjab, Karachi is almost a desert city with no natural blooms except for those that can survive the humid air and undernourished soil. But if a poem is ever written for Karachi, it will surely be about its unique gajra wallahs.

 

 

 

There are a couple of common sights that kids in Karachi grow accustomed to  - garbage, people littering the roads, throwing empty cans and wrappers from their cars, using the roadside as a public loo and disfiguring the walls in any possible way - be it the arty graffiti or the completely artless spit stains. There's hardly any public place in the city that would pass an international standard hygiene test. The last time I took my kids to Capri Cinema, we saw peekdaans placed in the middle of the main hall. They looked like little bird baths and were so precariously balanced that when a child (thankfully not mine) curiously looked into one, it got knocked over and the floor saw a flood of red. Not a pretty sight!

To cut a long story short, there's no easy way of teaching kids today the importance of cleanliness. To simply tell them that "cleanliness is half religion" in a classroom doesn't explain why a nation of 5 billion muslims can be so downright filthy. And so the battle of the soaps, Safeguard and Lifebuoy, came as healthy exposure. Safeguard began their Commander Safeguard campaign a couple of months ago and the 30 minute animations they run on television channels were so interesting that the kids sat glued to TV sets in anticipation. Whether their habits changed or not remains to be determined but it certainly got them talking. To challenge the characters of Commander Safeguard and his conquests on Disease Island came Lifebuoy and its adventures in Germcity. And recently this Germcity experience came to Karachi in a 3-day campaign that invited children for an educational evening of entertainment.

The grassy field of the National Coaching Centre was recreated as Germcity and makeshift schools, homes and playgrounds were set up. They were taken over by life size green germs and the children coming in had to attack them to rid the city of the dirt-evil. Each child entering the arena was given a red bandana and a quick karate lesson by a professional coach. He would then be ready to fight in any of the 'buildings'. While attacking germs, the kids also had to pick up litter and make sure that the place was clean.

The germ city opened into an elaborate food court that you could enter only after washing your hands. Several sinks were installed to make this possible. Most impressive, even the lifebuoy mobile toilets were clean, with running Ava water on hand. A job done well by Catwalk.

It was an event open to the masses and it was indeed heartening to see hundreds of school kids attending in uniform. In a city that severely lacks entertainment of any kind, it served as a double-edged sword that entertained as well as educated. Pleasant patriotic music played in the background and the Karachi breeze blew away the rising heat of the day. The kids were visibly have a great time and eagerly awaited every possible opportunity to take on the germs.

It's a great start but we, the citizens of Karachi, need nothing short of a revolution to clean up our act. Once the cleanest city of Asia, Karachi now looks like a wasteland. And no one is to blame but us. No one will come and clean up our mess until we determine to do it ourselves. Karachi needs paan to be banned from public places. Delhi faced similar cleanliness problems a few years back and authorities took a very unorthodox route to eliminating the curse of spitting in public buildings. They put up pictures of gods and goddesses everywhere. People, afraid of being sacrilegious, refrained from spitting anywhere near them. Funny as it sounds, it worked. Unfortunately goddesses cannot save us from the wrath of paan-chewers and tobacco spitters. Nor can we wish them away. Till then, even if our kids start washing their hands properly, it is a clean beginning.

 

 

"Give me 10 samosas". "Give me 15 samosas". "Please hand over the bowl of chat masala". These shouts can be continuously heard at the one rupee samosa canteen in Karachi University. Famous for its delicious, small sized, one rupee samosas, this canteen, undoubtedly, is the peculiarity of the place. While visiting the shop, many people take notice of the small boy sitting inside, engrossed in the almost mechanical act of making samosas. This 16-year-old boy is Umar Aslam.

Umar's parents migrated to Karachi from Peshawar many years back. Umar was born here and he doesn't even know the name of his village. Unlike the other boys of his age, Umar is a very serious, reserved and shy. His life revolves around his work and his family, which includes his parents and 9 siblings. This little chit chat with Umar reveals some of the aspects of his life in Karachi.

 

Kolachi: How long have you been working here?

Umar: I have been working in this shop for the last 7 years.

Kolachi: What are your timings?

Umar: I start working at 8 in the morning and I usually get free by 2pm.

Kolachi: How much do you earn?

Umar: They give me 120 rupees per day but during vacations there is no such workload so I get 100 rupees per day.

Kolachi: What you do with that money?

Umar: I give it to my father.

Kolachi: Do you not keep any money for yourself?

Umar: Yes I do. I get about 20 rupees everyday. I don't spend it. I save it and spend it during the Eid holidays.

Kolachi: Do you go to school?

Umar: No. I am not interested in studying. A brother of mine went to school but as I didn't have interest, my father never sent me.

Kolachi: Have you ever been to your village?

Umar: Yes. I visited my village last Ramazan for the first time. It's really a good place and I liked my village more than Karachi. I felt better there than I feel here.

Kolachi: How many samosas do you make each day?

Umar: (After thinking for some time) I think I make 1000 to 1500 samosas.

Kolachi. Did you ever get hurt while working?

Umar: When I started working, my hands got burnt quite often but now I am an expert at my work.

Kolachi: On which days do you take off and how do you spend your holidays?

Umar: I take Sundays off when I stay at home and rest for the whole day. I also watch TV. I like watching dramas but I don't like movies.

Kolachi: Which dramas?

Umar: I don't know their names. I just watch them.

Kolachi: Do you go for outings?

Umar: We go to Clifton and also to the Zoo. In Clifton, I go to the parks and take rides on the swings. At Zoo I like to take rides on the elephant.

Kolachi: Are you satisfied with your work?

Umar: Yes I like my work quite a lot.  

Kolachi: What are your plans for the future?

Umar: I haven't made any plans. Only time will decide my future.

Kolachi: Do you want to move to some other place?

Umar: Though I don't like the city, I don't want to move to any other place. I am satisfied with my life and my work here.

 

Living a thousand miles away from his native land, loving city life and hating it at the same time and yet unable to leave – such is Karachi's character.

 

 

|Home|Daily Jang|The News|Sales & Advt|Contact Us|


BACK ISSUES