|
Mom's
diet may influence baby's sex
Mothers-to-be
who eat better, deliver more boys -- but critics aren't so
sure
By Jonel Aleccia
In the quest
to select a baby's sex, success could depend on breakfast
cereal and better nutrition, according to a new study that may
offer some women another reason to eat their Wheaties.
Mothers-to-be
who skip breakfast and eat less are more likely to give birth
to girls, while moms
who consume more calories and a wider range of nutrients -
including, specifically, those from breakfast cereal - are
more likely to deliver sons. That's according to new research
by British scientists that provides what they say is the
first-ever evidence that a mother's diet at conception may
determine her baby's sex.
Researchers
from the universities of Exeter and Oxford in England asked
740 first-time moms in the United Kingdom to keep food diaries
before and during early pregnancy. The women didn't know the
sex of their babies, but when researchers reviewed their food
plans, they found that moms who consumed more calories of
higher quality before conceiving were about 24 percent more
likely to give birth to boys than moms who ate less.
"The
overall sex ratio in our population was close to 50:50, but
individual mothers had a greater chance of bearing male
offspring if their nutrient intake was high prior to
conception," wrote Fiona Mathews, the study's lead author
and a research fellow at the University of Exeter. "The
consumption of breakfast cereal was also strongly associated
with having a male infant."
Fifty-six
percent of women in the group with the highest energy intake
gave birth to boys, compared to 45 percent in the group with
the lowest energy consumption, according to the study.
Mothers of
boys consumed an average of 2,413 calories a day before
conception and higher amounts of foods containing potassium,
calcium and vitamins C, E and B12, the researchers said. Women
who had girls logged 2,283 calories a day and less protein,
vitamins and minerals.
Odds of
having a boy were much higher for women who ate at least one
bowl of breakfast cereal a day compared to women who ate less
than one bowl a week, the study said. Breakfast cereals are
usually fortified by vitamins and minerals.
Critics wary
of claims
Critics,
however, said the new research contradicts basic facts of
human genetics. A fath er's
sperm determines a child's sex, and there's no evidence that
maternal nutrition has anything to do with it, said Dr Paul
Magarelli, Vice President, Pacific Coast Reproductive Society.
"A
correlation does not make the truth," said Magarelli, who
is also director of the Reproductive Medicine and Fertility
Centre in Colorado Springs, Colo. "I think it's a
spurious correlation, that's all I can say."
The British
scientists said that although fathers do determine sex, their
research indicates that mothers' may be able to favour the
development of one sex over another, perhaps in the way that
high-glucose environments in in-vitro fertilisation appear to
favour male embryos and inhibit female embryos.
The research
is also supported by an evolutionary drive to produce more
offspring in times of plenty. In many animals - including
horses, cows and some species of deer - more males are
produced when a mother has more resources, the scientists
noted.
Skipping
breakfast, for instance, extends overnight fasting and
depresses glucose levels, which could be interpreted by the
body as a poor environment, researchers said.
Their
argument deserves further study, said Dr Tarun Jain, an
assistant professor of reproductive endocrinology at the
University of Illinois at Chicago. "It's not showing far
and away that if women eat a certain diet they'll have a boy
or a girl, but it certainly is giving us some
information," Jain said. "Could there be dietary
factors that influence conception?"
Diet trends
may explain fewer boys.
In addition
to suggesting that breakfast cereal may produce more boys, the
researchers said that nutrition and diet trends may account
for an incremental decline in male births in developing
nations. Over the last 40 years, births of boys have also
dropped by about one per 1000 births annually in the United
States, the U.K. and Canada, they said.
At the same
time, many young women in those developed nations have begun
skipping breakfast and eating poorer-quality diets.
"This
research may help explain why, in developed countries, where
many young women choose to have low-calorie diets, the
proportion of boys born is falling," Mathews said.
That's
counter to the trend in countries such as India, Vietnam and
China, where births of boys now outpace girls because parents
selective sex techniques, including abortion, to obtain highly
prized sons.
The new
study may influence mothers to try to use nutrition to select
sex, which worries ethicists such as Nigel Cameron, president
of the Institute on Biotechnology and the Human Future at the
Chicago-Kent College of Law at the Illinois Institute of
Technology.
"It
adds to the manipulative tool box whose purpose is designer
babies. We need a lot more social debate about the fact that
children should be received as-is," said Cameron. |