issue
Donors don’t give a dam
Diamer-Bhasha Dam is again in doldrums as the Asian 
Development Bank and the World Bank refuse to fund the project
By Aoun Sahi
Diamer-Bhasha dam is the most important under construction hydropower project in Pakistan at present. It is being constructed on the Indus River on the boundary of Gilgit-Baltistan and Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa. 
This USD12 billion project was unanimously approved by the Council of Common Interest (CCI) in July 2010, and in October 2011 former Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani inaugurated the project. 
The 272-metre high roller compacted concrete (RCC) dam will be the highest of this form of dams in the world after completion. The dam will store 8.1 million acre feet water with live water storage (useable) of 6.4 million acre feet and also produce 4,500 megawatts of hydropower. It will also help control flood damage downstream in the Indus during high floods. The dam will also enhance the life of Tarbela Dam by 35 years by trapping sedimentation upstream. 

Yeh Woh
Why to enjoy Eid
By Masud Alam
With the mobile phone companies offering ‘Good bye Ramzan’ ringtones; employees who haven’t worked for a whole month, scrambling to take off for an extended holiday; and food prices jumping up another notch in anticipation of Eid shopping rush, the holy month has come to an end and with it goes any semblance of normalcy in our daily lives.
It’s time for all sorts of jokers hoarding sawaab, barkat, and calories — not necessarily in the same order — in the confines of their comfortable farm houses, or acclimatising themselves for heaven in the cool climes of Europe, to come back refreshed and reinvigorated, to their true calling that is making our lives more miserable and deaths cheaper than they already are.

Coal-fired contention
Prime minister’s support for Thar coal gasification project has silenced voices of dissent for now. Is it a political stunt or a logical move?
By Shahzada Irfan Ahmed
Not long ago, the Pakistani government celebrated its decision to explore huge coal reserves available in Thar, Sindh to meet the country’s ever-increasing demand of energy and decrease dependence on imported fuels. It held road shows all over the world and invited foreign investors to try their luck here. 
The response was mixed. While some leading companies showed interest in the project, a few lenders including the World Bank expressed reservations against the option for being an environmental hazard. 

operation
Ready to ‘do more’
 Pakistan military now seems willing to go after militants in North Waziristan, but at the time of its own choosing as it has been arguing all along
By Rahimullah Yusufzai
The Pakistan government and military have yet to announce the launching of the long-awaited military operation against the militants in North Waziristan, but the United States Secretary of Defence Leon Panetta and unnamed Pentagon officials have publicly stated that the action in this troubled tribal region would begin soon. 
The Americans could be right as in the past also announcements about some important happenings in Pakistan were first made in the US. Panetta based his information on the recent conversations between the Pakistan Army chief General Ashfaq Parvez Kayani and the US and Nato military commander in Afghanistan, General John Allen. Kayani and Allen have held quite a few meetings in the recent months as the latter was closely involved in the eventually successful efforts by the US government officials to cut a deal with Pakistan to reopen the Nato supplies routes. 

The other side of
London Olympics
Ruling elite, Olympics organisers and the corporate masters
succeeded in banning and betraying the real sponsors of the
games – the Londoners
By Murtaza Ali Shah

The London Olympics 2012 have been described as the most exhilarating party on this earth but this was a scandalous party in which the very permanent residents of the city were not invited, effectively cast asunder, discouraged and bullied by the corporate elite. It’s a scandal of high proportions that the BBC would not like the outside world to know that the Olympics was largely a cosmetic, overblown public relations exercise, built on the back of taxes paid by middle-income Britons, in particular Londoners who were once again made to feel like aliens in their own homes. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

issue
Donors don’t give a dam
Diamer-Bhasha Dam is again in doldrums as the Asian 
Development Bank and the World Bank refuse to fund the project
By Aoun Sahi

Diamer-Bhasha dam is the most important under construction hydropower project in Pakistan at present. It is being constructed on the Indus River on the boundary of Gilgit-Baltistan and Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa.

This USD12 billion project was unanimously approved by the Council of Common Interest (CCI) in July 2010, and in October 2011 former Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani inaugurated the project.

The 272-metre high roller compacted concrete (RCC) dam will be the highest of this form of dams in the world after completion. The dam will store 8.1 million acre feet water with live water storage (useable) of 6.4 million acre feet and also produce 4,500 megawatts of hydropower. It will also help control flood damage downstream in the Indus during high floods. The dam will also enhance the life of Tarbela Dam by 35 years by trapping sedimentation upstream.

The dam, which Wapda — the executing agency of Diamer-Bhasha Dam Project — terms a highest priority, has received a massive blow as leading donors of the project, the Asian Development Bank and the World Bank, are not that keen to fund it.

“In June this year, the ADB communicated to Wapda about its concerns over the project while the World Bank is more interested in funding the 4,320MW Dasu dam project situated 70 kilometres downstream in Kohistan area of KPK,” a senior official of Wapda tells TNS.

This decision of the ADB would result in escalation of the construction cost of the project by more than USD1.5 billion.

“It would take at least two to three more years than scheduled time which means Pakistan would be deprived of at least USD5 billion in terms of annual benefits of the project,” says the Wapda official. The official adds that the main objection of the WB and the ADB is that the dam is situated in disputed territory of Kashmir. “In fact, it is done because of backdoor efforts of India. Interestingly, the same financing institutions had funded Mangla Dam project that was situated in Kashmir.”

On August 10, the issue was also discussed by Senate’s Committee on Water and Power. Chairman of the committee, Zahid Khan of the ANP, who presided over the meeting seemed inclined towards the WB offer on Dasu dam.

Wapda chairman Shakil Durrani told the committee, “The government’s priority is Bhasha dam, and not Dasu project, and the World Bank is not responsible for making policies in Pakistan. We have made it clear to all donors that Pakistan will not give preference to Dasu over Bhasha.”

Later talking to TNS, Durrani said, “If Bhasha is getting delayed why Wapda is not starting work on Dasu which is equally important. It will also provide almost similar megawatts of electricity. I have called a joint meeting of Wapda, Economic Division and Planning Division after Eid. They will have to tell us the real problem and the solutions of the issue. We face people while our bureaucrats sit in offices and make policies which suit them.”

A Wapda official says that Dasu is a run-of-the-river project which will store negligible water. “Water storage is a huge issue. The major reservoirs of the country have already lost around 30 per cent storage capacity due to sedimentation. At present, Tarbela Dam’s storage capacity is diminishing with 5,000 tons of silt filling its reservoir daily. The total water storage capacity of Tarbela, Mangla and Chashma stands at 14.22 million acre feet at present which is not enough for even 30 days.”

The official adds that work on both dams cannot be started simultaneously and if Wapda starts work on the Dasu project, Diamer-Bhasha project will be delayed at least for 10 years. “Work on Diamer-Bhasha dam is in advance stage while engineering design of Dasu dam would be completed in 2013,” he says.

The government of Pakistan so far, has spent Rs16 billion on the project. Rs7 billion has already been distributed among dam affectees through the Gilgit-Baltistan government.

“Besides acquiring land for the project, 13 local contracts for construction of colonies for Wapda officials and allied infrastructure for the dam have already been awarded while international competition bidding for the main construction of the dam can be initiated at any time,” a spokesperson for Wapda tells TNS.

With the ADB and the WB backing out, the government of Pakistan and Wapda are in contact with China, Islamic Development Bank and other bilateral and multilateral finance institutions.

A meeting of officials of Ministry of Water and Power and Wapda held at Islamabad on August 13 to discuss the latest situation of the project. The meeting discussed financial aspects of the project in details. The meeting decided to seek Chinese support to construct the dam.

“Financing a project like Diamer-Bhasha dam is not a big issue. The government and Wapda are committed to this project and soon will start main construction work. It is true that backing off of the ADB can delay the project for a couple of years, but it will be completed ultimately.”

 

Yeh Woh
Why to enjoy Eid
By Masud Alam

With the mobile phone companies offering ‘Good bye Ramzan’ ringtones; employees who haven’t worked for a whole month, scrambling to take off for an extended holiday; and food prices jumping up another notch in anticipation of Eid shopping rush, the holy month has come to an end and with it goes any semblance of normalcy in our daily lives.

It’s time for all sorts of jokers hoarding sawaab, barkat, and calories — not necessarily in the same order — in the confines of their comfortable farm houses, or acclimatising themselves for heaven in the cool climes of Europe, to come back refreshed and reinvigorated, to their true calling that is making our lives more miserable and deaths cheaper than they already are.

The most dutiful among them are the people charged with deciding how much electricity and gas the consumers need not have. The only state responsibility that is discharged responsibly, several times every day, without fail, is cutting off the supply of basic utilities. They have been at it even during Ramzan, despite promises to the contrary by the highest jokers in the state. They’ll come back with a vengeance and squeeze every last watt out of the supply chain to make up for the generosity shown on Independence Day, when apparently all of Pakistan had electricity, all day.

Fighters — of both uniformed and shalwar-qamees variety — will also be quick in returning. They haven’t done any killings in a while and they are dying for some action. The war theatre for Pakistani soldiers and Pakistani civilians, we are told by the all-knowing Americans, will be North Waziristan. The military action will produce hundreds of thousands of fresh IDPs (internally displaced persons) and millions of dollars for the military. It will also help us forget the utter failure of another military operation being carried out in South Waziristan for nearly three years, during which only one of the six sub-divisions has been cleared for IDPs to return.

Politicians have their plate full. Leaders of two parties were busy disrobing each other in public when a truce was imposed in respect of the last ten days of Ramzan. They will come back to resume debating the character of each other’s parents, wives and children, and waving documentary evidence to support their claims and blames. The ruling parties need to work out in what manner to send their incumbent PM home and make some more money in electing the next. The Khan will lead million men into South Waziristan where even the local administrators and elected representatives don’t work or live. And all the politicians will come clamouring for elections because that’s the only part of democracy they know, care about, invest in, and enjoy.

One reason for the government employees — from a clerk and policeman to a director general and secretary — to stop working during Ramzan is their reluctance to demand or accept bribes during the holy month, and that leaves nothing else for them to do. They’ll come back having calculated their lost earnings, and having upwardly revised their rates accordingly. Getting the signature of a government servant — which is all anyone can get out of them — will cost a lot more starting this fall.

Pakistan’s seedy media uses the above mentioned jokers and their performances as oil for its wheels. Minus the lubricant the wheels have been creaking and grinding. Newspapers have had to fill the pages with international news and drab comments by unpaid contributors; radio has had to throw in hamd and qawwali in place of racy Bollywood songs; and television became decidedly bland and boring despite the marketing teams’ best efforts to repackage Islam for telly and sell it for profit. This industry needs at least a dozen more Aalims Online.

Too much piety has been spilled in the last month to last us another eleven. It’s time for dishing out cheap and cheerful entertainment and sleaze-laced news and current affairs this media cooks best. Men on television can loosen their tongues and women can let the dupatta slip and their hair down, now that Allah has stopped prying into their studios and everyone’s lives. The nation that changes its character according to the month of the year, is switching into high gear. Watch out little guys.

But hey, it’s Eid, and there’s got to be something to cheer, to be happy about. There is. The government has announced three holidays that end on Wednesday. But following a rigid national tradition, holidaymakers won’t be back till Sunday. That gives us a whole week of Ramzan-like inactivity and serenity. Let’s enjoy it while it lasts.

masudalam@yahoo.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Coal-fired contention
Prime minister’s support for Thar coal gasification project has silenced voices of dissent for now. Is it a political stunt or a logical move?
By Shahzada Irfan Ahmed

Not long ago, the Pakistani government celebrated its decision to explore huge coal reserves available in Thar, Sindh to meet the country’s ever-increasing demand of energy and decrease dependence on imported fuels. It held road shows all over the world and invited foreign investors to try their luck here.

The response was mixed. While some leading companies showed interest in the project, a few lenders including the World Bank expressed reservations against the option for being an environmental hazard.

The government allocated a couple of blocks in Thar to private companies for conventional mining, but at the same time launched an Underground Coal Gasification (UGC) project to counter opposition on environmental grounds. This technology converts underground coal into gas while it is still in the coal seam, and this gas is pushed to the surface and can be extracted from there.

Three years down the road, this project, headed by renowned nuclear scientist Dr Samar Mubarakmand, is at the centre of a controversy with supporters and opponents of the idea at loggerheads with each other. At one time the odds are in the favour of the doctor and at another in the favour of the opponents.

Recently, the project got a new lease of life when the prime minister released Rs900 million for it which were long overdue. Prior to that, there was a lot of bickering on whether the project is viable or mere waste of the country’s resources. The worst blow came from Shahid Sattar, Member Planning Commission, who declared the project non-feasible claiming the flame at a Thar well could hardly burn for around four hours. Dr Samar Mubarkmand responded in no time claiming the said member had not even visited the site but was badmouthing on behest of vested interests.

Irrespective of who is right and who is wrong, one thing is for sure. The people of Pakistan are confused and in a fix. They are not clear whether the plans worth billions to produce gas, diesel and electricity through coal gasification in Thar will materialise or just fizzle away. TNS contacted various stakeholders and experts for a better understanding of the issue and received comments in the favour of and against the project.

A production engineer in a gas exploration company in Pakistan believes UCG is viable in Thar but the biggest issue is how to check the influx of underground water. The water level is quite high in the area and in many cases it is too close to surface which makes it difficult for the underground coal seam to burn, he says.

Coal available in Thar, he says, is lignite which is a low-rank fuel due to high moisture and incombustible content. Transportation of lignite over long distances is not feasible and it is preferred to treat it close to the deposit. Foreign companies have dropped the idea of conventional mining of Thar coal in the past when they found it was not so hard and dry, he adds.

The claim of risk to water reserves is backed by a Thardeep Rural Development Programme (TRDP) study which terms the likely depletion of natural aquifiers the biggest casualty of coal exploration programme. It adds there are three acquifiers — one at the surface, second just above where the coal is and the third lies beneath the layers of coal.

Quite interestingly, the opposition to UGC in Thar is based not on these grounds but on the assumed failure of the project team to show encouraging results. And this has come mainly from some members of the Planning Commission (PC), on which Dr Samar Mubarakmand also has a representation as Member, Science and Technology.

TNS contacted Shahid Sattar, Member Energy PC, to seek his views on the project but he refused to talk on the issue, saying he is not the spokesman for the commission. The next person to approach was Dr Nadeem-ul-Haq, Deputy Chairman PC, who said the version of the commission was the same as given by the prime minister of Pakistan, who also happens to be the chairman of the commission. The appreciation of the prime minister has come in the form of release of funds and additional salary payment to the whole team in recognition of their achievements.

Dr Samar tells TNS the project is a roaring success and delay, if any, has been solely due to the suspensions of required funds. It is a pity that an outgoing secretary of the Planning Commission ensured that not a single penny was released for the project during his tenure, he adds. He says it’s a reality that power generation from Thar coal would cost between Rs three and Rs four per unit and diesel production from coal gas would cost $40 a barrel. “One can imagine the profits involved as diesel is costing $135 per barrel to the people of Pakistan.” The cost, he says, is a bit higher than that in South Africa which produces diesel for $25 a barrel and China where it costs $28 a barrel.

Dr Samar says he has received expressions of interest from several international companies who are willing to invest in Thar even without a sovereign guarantee. “They are seeing profits but those watching vested interests can’t.” The PM and his team as well as media personnel themselves experienced how strongly the coal gas was rising from the well, he states.

He condemns a local daily for carrying unsubstantiated claims about the non-viability of the project and not carrying the reply he forwarded to them. The paper, he says, gave too much space to a person who wrote UGC is not in use anywhere in the world. He should have known that several countries including Russia, Canada, Uzbekistan, Australia and China are widely benefiting from the use of this technology.

Countering the allegations against the project, he claims that a gas flame had continued to burn for almost four and half months and extinguished due to suspension in funds. There are 38 other wells where such flames can be lit any time.

He says there are 14 preconditions which have to be confirmed before initiating a coal gasification project. Fortunately, Thar coal field fulfills all these conditions. For example, the coal should be lignite, sulphur content should be one per cent or less, depth should be more than 100 meters, thickness of coal seam should be more than 2 meters, there should be road links and pipelines for transportation of diesel and gas, soil should be solid and free of cracks to stop gas from escaping etc. Oil seam here is on average between 10 metres to 20 metres thick, he says, adding no one came forward to challenge the project on these grounds.

Dr Samar is happy to have funds at his disposal but asks for more as the current tranche will be spent on procuring machinery and clearing the dues. These Rs 900 million had to be disbursed before June 30 but were withheld intentionally to harm the project.

He gets extremely uneasy when asked to go for a third-party evaluation of the project. “Do you still think there’s a need for it? Is the whistling sound of gas gushing through the well top not enough to establish our success?”

 

 

 


operation
Ready to ‘do more’
 
Pakistan military now seems willing to go after militants in North Waziristan, but at the time of its own choosing as it has been arguing all along
By Rahimullah Yusufzai

The Pakistan government and military have yet to announce the launching of the long-awaited military operation against the militants in North Waziristan, but the United States Secretary of Defence Leon Panetta and unnamed Pentagon officials have publicly stated that the action in this troubled tribal region would begin soon.

The Americans could be right as in the past also announcements about some important happenings in Pakistan were first made in the US. Panetta based his information on the recent conversations between the Pakistan Army chief General Ashfaq Parvez Kayani and the US and Nato military commander in Afghanistan, General John Allen. Kayani and Allen have held quite a few meetings in the recent months as the latter was closely involved in the eventually successful efforts by the US government officials to cut a deal with Pakistan to reopen the Nato supplies routes.

Pakistan for the last few years has resisted the US pressure to undertake military operation in North Waziristan and specifically target the Haqqani network, a potent faction of the Afghan Taliban movement founded by mujahideen commander Maulvi Jalaluddin Haqqani and presently led by his 34-year-old son Sirajuddin Haqqani. However, it seems the Pakistan military is now willing to do the job, but at the time of its own choosing as it has been arguing all along. Besides, it won’t be going after the Haqqanis despite the US demand and, if one were to believe Panetta, the main target of the military operation in North Waziristan would be the Pakistani Taliban.

Though the US would have been happier if the Pakistanis had agreed to first target the Haqqani network, the military operation in North Waziristan to some extent would help its cause in the challenging environment of the Af-Pak region as the Pakistani Taliban, led by Hakimullah Mahsud, haven’t hidden their ambition to target American interests and had, on one occasion, come close to achieving it by training Faisal Shahzad to carry out the aborted car-bombing at the busy Times Square in New York.

The US authorities would be hoping, and not without reason, that the Haqqani network and the Pakistani Taliban led by Hafiz Gul Bahadur, whose peace agreement with the government is intact, would be gradually drawn into the fighting in North Waziristan and the Pakistan military would have no choice but to fight them also along with the militants belonging to the Hakimullah Mahsud-headed Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP).

The priority for the Pakistan military certainly would be to take on the TTP elements that have found sanctuaries in North Waziristan after being evicted from most of their strongholds in parts of neighbouring South Waziristan populated by the Mahsud tribe as a result of the army action in October 2009. Together with likeminded militants from the different jehadi groups and remnants of al-Qaeda and Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan (IMU), the TTP has become strong and entrenched in North Waziristan despite the apparent displeasure of the non-TTP Taliban faction of Hafiz Gul Bahadur.

The military would be careful not to alienate Hafiz Gul Bahadur as it goes after the TTP while undertaking targetted operation as there would be the risk of pushing him into a corner to make a common cause with Hakimullah Mahsud. Until now the government and its intelligence agencies have worked hard to keep the militant factions divided by cutting peace deals with commanders Hafiz Gul Bahadur in North Waziristan and Maulvi Nazeer in South Waziristan and fighting the TTP, but this strategy could unravel in the event of a careless move or high number of civilian casualties. The US too could prove a spoiler by continuing drone strikes without coordinating with the Pakistan military or doing nothing as has been the case until now to check the cross-border attacks by the Maulana Fazlullah-led Pakistani militants operating from the eastern Afghan provinces of Kunar and Nuristan.

In fact, another nightmare for Pakistan would be the possibility that Pakistani militants from North and South Waziristan, as a result of the military operation, could cross over to Afghanistan as happened with the Taliban from Swat and rest of Malakand division and then launch cross-border attacks into the Pakistani territory.

The military’s reasons for not launching military action in North Waziristan until now included the military being stretched fighting already on many fronts in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (Fata) and Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, the need for consolidating gains made in other conflict areas before opening a new front, and the lack of resources for undertaking the new operation and caring for the thousands of tribal people who would be displaced. After all most of the tribal people displaced from South Waziristan two and a half years ago after the military operation are yet to be repatriated and resettled.

Another reason, which isn’t mentioned, was the still intact peace accord between the government and the Taliban faction led by Hafiz Gul Bahadur, who isn’t part of the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) and is arguably the most powerful militant commander in North Waziristan. Besides, Pakistan has been arguing that it was time for the US to talk to the Afghan Taliban, including the Haqqanis, instead of fighting them after Nato’s failure to force a military solution of the Afghan conflict.

It is a fact that Pakistani authorities had never ruled out a military operation in North Waziristan. Rather, one major military action was undertaken in 2004 that continued for almost two years and was followed by a peace accord in September 2006 with Hafiz Gul Bahadur and the tribal elders. The peace agreement was renewed following another round of skirmishes in the subsequent years.

Due to convergence of so many militants of different persuasion in North Waziristan and the threat emanating from there to the Pakistani state, the government and the military were under tremendous pressure to go after the militant sanctuaries. One could say that the military showed patience in the face of provocative acts by the militants who attacked soldiers and continued challenging the writ of the state and hosting foreigners.

It seems the militants’ attack on the Pakistan Air Force airbase at Kamra on Thursday and the claim of responsibility for it by the TTP would finally force the military’s hands to expedite plans for the operation in North Waziristan.

 

 

 

 

 

 

The other side of 
London Olympics
Ruling elite, Olympics organisers and the corporate masters
succeeded in banning and betraying the real sponsors of the
games – the Londoners
By Murtaza Ali Shah

The London Olympics 2012 have been described as the most exhilarating party on this earth but this was a scandalous party in which the very permanent residents of the city were not invited, effectively cast asunder, discouraged and bullied by the corporate elite. It’s a scandal of high proportions that the BBC would not like the outside world to know that the Olympics was largely a cosmetic, overblown public relations exercise, built on the back of taxes paid by middle-income Britons, in particular Londoners who were once again made to feel like aliens in their own homes.

That these were people’s sports and would “inspire a generation” was a crude joke to Londoners who paid £9billion for these games but were shunted out to make space for the filthy rich, oil oligarchs, Arab sheikhs and Britain’s own rich class that is a minority. But it’s the same ruling class that ended up watching the games, winning the medals and has everything to gain in the aftermath of these games.

In reality, these games belonged to capitalist brands Coca Cola, Mcdonald’s, Visa, Cadbury, ArcelorMittal, BMW and BP. The “official sponsors” contributed only £800million but they determined the nature of the games and their brand enforces acted like Taliban to implement and protect their brands’ promotion and the state bended over happily to accommodate them. A walk in the Olympics Park demonstrated at every step who are the real owners of these games.

Long before the games began, the disadvantaged communities of East London found their roads closed on them for the Olympics luminaries, restrictions imposed on their daily lives, racial minorities stopped and searched by a police which remains deeply racist, communities put within the range of missile strikes, their houses taken over almost on gunpoint for military sites — their life, work, leisure and everything else disrupted, hundreds of them literally cleansed prior to the games to make way for the Olympic village. With the games over, thousands more are now facing eviction from their homes where they have lived for decades.

The government can make any grandiose boast about these games but it will not rub away the fact that these games have torn communities apart and even worse is to come as more space is created for the affluent and the corporate sharks.

The right-wing Tory cabinet and London’s Tory Mayor, all of them private school educated with vast sports facilities available, are already gearing up for another go at power after next general election, holding up the London Olympics as a proof of their organisational brilliance. The mainstream media is silent over the ugly aspect of these games as it needs to put up a frivolous nationalistic fervour to keep the minds distracted from the bad news, but the scale of the scandal is so big that it cannot be buried. The mood of jubilation will pass and when the hype subsides to a manageable proportion, it will be the victims of London Olympics 2012 who will stare ahead into darkness, alone and helpless.

Left-wing campaigner and intellectual Lindsey German shared her grief over the plight of tens of thousands of victims, most located around the Olympics Park. “We ask what the legacy of these games will be — continued housing crisis while more flats are built for the rich, few sports facilities for East End kids?

“Meanwhile, inequality grows in one of the richest cities in the world. The world media is taken in by this spectacle but we have seen protests over a range of issues. After the games the real economic crisis will become clear and resentment against the games will grow further,” she told this correspondent.

But there are not many alternative voices coming forth, for the spectacle was so big and the so-called good news so soothing that many have felt repressed to talk about it. Britain’s left, democrats and anyone who cares for fundamental human rights of fellow human beings should have been in uproar over this, but it seems that the very people who make a living out of the human rights industry are blinded in their false belief that communities in Britain have reached the pinnacle of equality and they don’t need more human rights.

Watching the opening ceremony, I caught the sight of Shami Chakrabarti carrying the Olympics flag with the likes of a frail, pushed-out legendary boxer Muhamamd Ali, Ban-ki Moon, the United Nations secretary general and Doreen Lawrence, the mother of Stephen Lawrence, the black teenager killed in 1993 by racists in a deprived London area.

I thought for a moment that this is the best chance for the Liberty Director and known rights campaigner to say something – anything – or make a point aimed at highlighting the violation of the rights of her own fellow countrymen — ordinary, decent men and women who sponsored these games but have been sidelined — for it would have been the biggest worldwide audience she would ever get in her lifetime but that was not to be. It looked that the left-wing celebrity had been sucked in the bottomless pit of celebrity dazzle and glamour. Her participation proved that the left has been overwhelmed by the big business. For the left to sit on the plaudits that the so-called success of the opening ceremony is accredited to the left-wing director Danny Boyle is not enough. There is so much at stake here.

During the Beijing Olympics, the western media and the intellectual class went in overdrive to trample upon China on its human rights records, highlighting how the Olympics was built on the blood of the poor communities. That was a right position to take although the element of China-hatred was dominant. But where is that criticism when working class communities, surrounding the Olympic village, are paying for the privileged.

For tens of thousands of East Londoners, who put up with dust, dirt and noise for 8 years of construction in the run up to the Olympics, these games happened a few yard from their homes but these games might as well have been happening in another part of the world. Using school children from a local school to win Olympics in 2005, the London Olympics organisers had promised these games will belong to the local multi-cultural communities but the local people neither had the capacity to buy tickets or tickets were sold out too early or blocked by the corporate sponsors for their clients. The local Newham Council has told many residents that they will be evicted from the council estates soon to sell the high rise tower blocks to property developers.

Julian Cheyne, a campaigner who has spoken against the Olympics, has a personal experience of being evicted from his home prior to the start of the games by the Newham Council. He told The News on Sunday that International Olympics Committee’s (IOC) requires the host countries to create an Olympic Park and other facilities. This can be used as a justification for compulsory purchase of land in poor areas and the removal of the people occupying the land, he said.

“Compulsory purchase allows land to be purchased at knock down prices and then sold on to new richer owners. Stratford is extremely well connected with multiple railway and bus connections. The Olympics resulted in the removal of almost 5000 ‘dirty’ industrial jobs to be replaced, so it is hoped, by clean creative type jobs. The follow on process is to expand this Olympic zone into neighbouring areas and reshape East London.”

The official London 2012 slogan “Inspire a generation” was disingenuous. The right-leaning coalition government has introduced some of the harshest austerity squeezes and games in the state school system, attended by pupils from low-income backgrounds, are now non-existent. For the tiny minority of rich kids in private elite schools (only 7 per cent), sports facilities are of world class and it’s the students of these schools who won medals for Britain in Beijing and now in London.

Prime Minister David Cameron has called for more competitiveness in school sports but he has no idea what life is like for a working class kid in a tough state school. This government of multi-millionaires actually scrapped a target for pupils to do two hours of sports per week, effectively depriving millions of children from taking part in sports. If they had their way, they would allocate funds for those who were born in privilege and with medals in their mouths.

The organisers paraded Mo Farah, a Somali refugee and Muslim, as the new face of British nationalism but a look at the history of racism and immigration in Britain will tell that this is the biggest fallacy. For the majority he will remain the “other” – “oh Mo, you are different from other Somalis, different from other Muslims. You are untypical.” The question is will the one man’s success usher into anything positive for tens of thousands of “others” who are still aliens, foreigners, forever different?

Now that the lavish jamboree of international goodwill is over, what’s next? Campaigners, opposition politicians and media needs to step up pressure on the government to do something about the future of local children and youth, who are unemployed in their thousands and have nothing better to do with their lives. It’s the same people of youth who had risen against endless discrimination and alienation only a year ago when England was hit by the worst urban riots — claiming three British Pakistani martyrs, who died defending their communities against the looters.

Lest the world forgets, the areas around Olympics were the flashpoints of the riots which exposed the ugly face of Britain to the world after an un-armed Black youth Mark Dugga was gunned down by the police. Dozens of Olympic spectacles put together and the glamour faces projected for the world’s consumption will do nothing to tackle the deep seated problems of unemployment and the alienation of the youth. The establishment has failed to address the causes of those riots. The London Olympics has coincided with the first anniversary of the riots and the simmering tensions are there. The age of unrest is all around East London, the pressure cooker may combust anytime.

The writer is a London correspondent for Geo television and Jang Group of Newspapers. He can be contacted at Murtaza.shah@geo.tv

 

 



|Home|Daily Jang|The News|Sales & Advt|Contact Us|

 


BACK ISSUES