Bilal Akhtar of Aunty Disco Project was right in his analogy about
Coke Studio and the Pakistan cricket team. "It's like cricket.
It's bringing the nation together, evoking strong emotions and getting
an opinion from almost everybody."
As the fifth and final episode of Coke Studio airs tonight, there
is a lot that can be said about this year's show. Amidst a seemingly
dead climate of entertainment or fashion weeks (if you're into that
sort of thing), Coke Studio continues to charm audiences.
But this year, the show has also been subject to criticism, the
first time since its beginning three years ago. "Too much folk"
or no "Atif" or "Ali Zafar" etc.
But the artists showcased this season say it all. A few have fumbled
their way through the season while others have been pure knockouts.
But together it leads to one conclusion: Coke Studio is setting
a standard of performance that has never existed before. From the
sound to the studio itself, the visuals to the house band and the
scale of production to the musical ideas that flow, it's a standard
that is unmatched.
This season: Highs and lows
"No artist is too small or too big for Coke Studio," says
producer Rohail Hyatt. It is with this notion acts like ADP, EP
and Karavan found themselves on Coke Studio. They don't exactly
bring the kind of ratings or popularity that Atif Aslam or Ali Zafar
can whip up. But Coke Studio is for everyone, maintain its producers.
What this season has clearly demonstrated is the need to be open
to ideas and improvisation. It's this character that differentiates
Noori from Karavan, Meesha Shafi from EP, et al.
Bands do need to get their act together and they need some kind
of vision before entering the studio. As producer Rohail Hyatt certainly
gives them direction but the desire to experiment and reach out
is essential. It's necessary when other acts include the likes of
Abida Parveen (whose vocals alone can set the stage on fire) and
Tina Sani (a musical giant in her own right), our pop acts cannot
go in, rehash their hit songs and expect to make an impact.
As the third season is wrapping, it's becoming clear that while
producer Rohail Hyatt maintains the show is for everyone, it needs
artists to think outside the musical box.
Take Karavan, ADP and EP this season. Karavan's 'Yaadein' and 'Kaise
Mumkin' and EP's 'Bolo Bolo' - they were decent at best and clichéd
and boring at worst.
For EP, Coke Studio was a big moment. After a break-up and one album
that released seven years ago (Irtiqa, 2003), EP should've done
something different. Instead they toned down Sajjad Ali with 'Bolo
Bolo' and didn't exactly bring anything extraordinary to the table.
And that's the key to shining at Coke Studio. You need to be EXTRAORDINARY.
Same was the case with Karavan. They were good but were they as
memorable as Noori on season two? Hardly.
In comparison, ADP's 'Sultanat' with its grungy guitar solo, darbuka
on fire and OBA displaying his front-man skills was a rocking performance,
the kind one wished EP had put up.
Coke Studio puts together some of the most seasoned players in its
house band and every year it evolves. This year the backing vocalists
comprising of Saba Shabbir and new additions Sanam Saeed and Zoey
Viccaji is a lethal trio.
These girls are so good that they merit a song together. And it
makes sense. Coke Studio is already serving as a platform to showcase
Some of the other highlights include Arif Lohar. He deserves the
rock icon credit this season. His ideas of metal on 'Mirza Sahibaan'
leave no room for discussion. It's a deadly heavy metal tune and
it's brilliant. Arif had no inhibitions and he was clear unlike
our EP boys whose confusion hurdled its way over to the BTS (behind
the scene) footage of the show with Fawad asking his bandmates "what
are we doing, again?" I mean, you should have been planning
out what you would do since Rohail Hyatt approached you to come
For all the bands, this was a national moment, a chance to come
out of their comfortable cosmopolitan zone and right onto the mainstream.
But only ADP made that reach. EP and Karavan just didn't cut it,
not yet so far. They still have one song to go each. One more song
for every artist, a chance for redemption and glory…
Meanwhile the comeback kids, Noori and Zeb and Haniya continue to
defy expectations with their good and their bad ditties. The collaboration
between the two artists wasn't as intriguing or exciting as we hoped.
'Tann Dolay' is signature Noori. It's another decent floating number
that isn't memorable. But Noori and Zeb and Haniya understand the
experimental fun of Coke Studio.
Zeb and Haniya introduced us to Afghanistan's 'Bibi Sanam Janem'
and the Turkish delight, 'Nazaar Eyle' this season while Noori alongside
their mom Noor Zehra introduced the instrument Saagar Veena and
an old tune, a rendition of Hamid Ali Bela's 'Hor Vi Neevan Ho'.
They could've just done another 'Tann Dolay' but they didn't and
this gives Noori an edge, it gives Zeb and Haniya an edge over other
artists who continue to play out the same ideas.
All this takes us back to the older seasons, where it all began.
Only artists who have understood the ethos of Coke Studio have managed
success in the long haul. Ali Zafar is a shining example. On season
one, he reinvented some of his most popular numbers but his shining
moment came with 'Allah Hoo' on which he collaborated with Saeen
Tufail Ahmed. It was a breakthrough moment for a 'pop' star known
for his often cheesy love tunes. Ali picked up on the fact that
it was his Eastern 'Allah Hoo' that had caught attention. In '09
when season two aired, one didn't hear Ali belting more pop wonders.
Instead he switched to the Eastern side and came up with the magnificent
'Dastaan-e-Ishq', 'Nahin Ray Nahin' and Ustad M Jumman's timeless
'Yaar Dhadee'. Ali Zafar was a sensation as he broke all preconceived
notions about plastic pop.
There is also Noori who reinvented itself with Coke Studio. The
band had all but disappeared and when Coke Studio came calling last
year, Noori answered with 'Aik Alif' and 'Saari Raat Jaga'. They
didn't shy away from unknown territory and perhaps it's this reason
why Saeen Zahoor and Noori together on 'Aik Alif' are still hypnotic.
With each song Noori scored higher with old fans and created new
ones. It was this character that made them bigger that season than
either Shafqat Amanat Ali Khan (who remains a huge disappointment)
and even Atif Aslam. In Atif's case, even he tried things differently,
choosing unlikely numbers from his record to sing out loud, leaving
a lasting impression.
Eastern folk: a sign of the times
Like season one and two, where Ali Zafar and Ali Hamza (Noori) were
the breakthrough stars, this season that honour must go to Meesha
Shafi. Unknown beyond music circles, Meesha is a powerhouse of potential
talent and what makes her even more dynamic is that she's willing
to push the envelope. Obviously, her being very easy on the eyes
Her collaboration with Arif Lohar on 'Alif Allah' is this year's
biggest hit while her rendition of Reshma's 'Chori Chori' contains
explosive verve. Meesha dared to be different, she is the anti-thesis
to Zeb and Haniya and it works. Another artist who is shockingly
good is Amanat Ali. Instead of reworking songs from his abysmal
debut album, Kohram, Amanat Ali choose to reinvent 'Aisha' in his
own pop-esque ballad way and it sounds fantastic. 'Aisha' is the
kind of stuff he should be attempting on his own album. Anyway,
his collaboration with the delightful Sanam Marvi on 'Haq Maujood'
is trippy. Amanat Ali and Meesha Shafi are young players in the
music industry and these performances will go a long way for them.
It's important to realize that Coke Studio's appeal extends beyond
local shores. It's watched in India and across the board. It's a
critical platform that can build stars, create new identities, introduce
old acts in a different shade, re-invent some names and in a country
where musical activity is slow and unprofessional, this show is
even more important. And with every passing year, it is gaining
Coke Studio isn't just any musical platform. It's fusion and history,
regional languages and ancient kafis coming together in a modern
melting pot of music. Artists like Fakir Juman Shah and Sanam Marvi
can only come forward on a national platform that Coke Studio has
become. The view that some of these acts are too refined in their
art to be understood may represent a viewpoint. But it is the standard
of Coke Studio that makes it acceptable for these acts to be on
this stage. Where else have we heard Sanam Marvi before or such
slick recording of the Fakirs? It is refreshing to see that Rizwan
and Muazzam Qawwal (they maybe unknown to Pakistan but they perform
all over the world representing Pakistan) are not contained in a
four-minute pop song fashion. And its only when acts like Sanam
Marvi, a voice of Sindh meets Amanat Ali, a trained pop singer,
when true musical fusion takes place. And that's the standard of
As the final episode runs tonight with tunes from Tina Sani and
Abida Parveen as well as all the other featured acts of this season,
one thing is clear, musicians need to re-think their act when they
get a call on Coke Studio. The fact that its open to all is commendable
and needed - young acts like ADP must get that nudge for commercial
and creative reasons - but the music industry must consider it an
opportunity and bring out their A-game.
Throughout the seasons, it's not the veteran pop giants who have
left a huge mark. It's the experiments of Ali Zafar and Noori that
have worked. The naysayers for folk will continue to chant. But
this year the focus has been on folk and rightly so. It's the fusion
of Eastern folk with modern elements, the commercial and not-so-commercial
coming together that makes Coke Studio so appealing. Coke Studio
can't simply be a place to reinvent old pop songs. It is more than
a few pop songs. We've seen and heard pop reinventions; it's time
to make way for the daringly different and original, the Fakirs
of Bhit Shah and the Kalams of Bulley Shah, now more pertinent to
the times than ever, cannot be ignored. It may be sophisticated
the languages may vary, but discovery and learning are a part of
the journey. Coke Studio has just opened the door.